The short answer: Don't start with what the practice down the street charges. Start with how many patients you can take care of well, what the practice has to earn, and what you've promised to include. Then do the division. If the number makes you squirm, pay attention. It's usually telling you something.
Why you left insurance matters for your price
Most physicians I work with didn't move to a membership model because they wanted something fancy. They left because insurance pays for visits. It doesn't pay for time.
Medicare physician payment has dropped about a third since 2001 once you adjust for what it costs to run a practice, according to the AMA. Meanwhile your rent, your staff, and your malpractice went the other direction. And even when the numbers tick up a little, the system is still paying for the appointment. It isn't paying for the call with the cardiologist, the 8 p.m. message, or the hour you spend untangling a complicated patient.
That unpaid work is the whole reason membership medicine exists. So your price has to be built around it. If it isn't, you've left insurance and recreated the same problem with a different logo.
The mistake I see over and over
Physicians price by looking around. What's the going rate? What did a consultant say? What feels reasonable?
Market numbers are fine as context. But they describe other people's practices, with other people's costs and other people's definition of "included." None of that tells you what your practice needs to charge.
How to price it: start with capacity
You need four answers.
1. How many patients can you actually take care of well? Not how many you could cram in. How many can you serve while still having evenings, weekends, and a working brain? The more access you promise, the smaller the panel. That's just how it works.
2. What does the practice need to earn? Your take-home, staff, rent, malpractice, software, the labs and supplies you plan to absorb, marketing, and some margin so the practice itself is healthy. Add it up. That's your revenue target.
3. Divide. Revenue target divided by panel size is the annual fee you need per patient.
4. Gut-check it against your community. Can the patients you want to serve afford it, and will they see why it's worth it? Better to find that out on paper than in month eight.
What a $10,000 membership looks like in real life
Let's say you want to run a very high-touch practice and charge $10,000 per patient per year, about $833 a month. (These numbers are made up to show the math. Plug in your own.)
Say you want $500,000 in practice revenue. At $10,000 per patient, that's 50 patients.
Here's how that might shake out:
Revenue: 50 patients × $10,000 = $500,000
Staff: $120,000
Rent, malpractice, software, and everything else it takes to keep the doors open: $70,000
Labs, testing, and supplies you've decided to include: $60,000
What's left for you: about $250,000
Now compare. To bring in that same $500,000 at $2,000 per patient, you'd need 250 patients. That's five times the people, more messages, more calls, more same-day requests, and the same number of hours in your week.
So the real question isn't "Is $10,000 too much?" It's "Which practice do I want to run?" Fifty patients you know inside and out, or two hundred and fifty you're constantly catching up on. Charging more isn't about being fancy. It's what lets you keep the panel small enough to deliver the thing you're charging for.
What has to be true to charge $10,000
A fee like that comes with a big promise, and the promise has to be real. Patients paying at this level expect to feel the difference the first week, not the first year. Before you set the price, get specific about:
Access. How fast do you respond, and during what hours? What does "24/7" actually mean? True emergencies only? Anything urgent? Who hears about it first, you, a nurse, a coordinator?
What's included. Be deliberate. If a service costs you real time or supplies, decide on purpose whether it's included, discounted, or an add-on. At this price, people expect more included, and you need to have priced that in.
What patients experience. At this level, people expect you to know them, remember them, and coordinate their care without being chased. That means someone ahead of them on the details: scheduling, follow-ups, specialist referrals, records. If your systems can't do that yet, fix that before you raise the price, not after.
Who has the money conversation. If you hate talking about fees, don't be the one doing it. Have someone else handle the first call and the enrollment, so you can show up for the patient, not the invoice.
Who it's for. A $10,000 membership serves a smaller slice of your community. That's fine, but be honest about whether enough of those people live near you, or whether your model needs to reach further.
Set the access boundaries on day one. They're nearly impossible to walk back later, and they decide how many patients you can really handle, which loops straight back to your price.
Where the money quietly leaks
Even at $10,000, the fee isn't usually the problem. It's everything that got thrown in for free.
Everything bundled, nothing priced. Free procedures, free injections, labs at your cost, unlimited everything. Each one feels generous on its own. Together they can turn a healthy fee into one that barely covers the work.
Founding-member deals that never end. A founder's rate is a great launch tool when it has an end date. Without one, you've handed someone a permanent discount.
Pricing for the practice you used to have. If you're narrowing your focus, your pricing should follow the new model, not the old one.
No annual review. Your costs go up every year. A fee that never changes is a pay cut you gave yourself.
Monthly or annual?
Monthly is easy to say yes to and easy to leave. Annual gives you steadier revenue and a stronger commitment, and at this price point many practices lean that way. Rules about refunds and proration on prepaid memberships vary by state, so run your structure past a healthcare attorney before you build it. Plenty of practices offer both, with a small incentive for annual.
If you're already in practice and too low
If you've realized your current fee doesn't cover the work, you don't have to flip a switch overnight.
Pick the new number first, using the capacity math above.
Give real notice. Sixty to ninety days is common.
Tell people what the fee pays for. Patients handle increases better when they understand them.
Grandfather existing members, but with a deadline.
Expect a few people to leave. That's okay. It frees up room for patients who value what you do.
The bigger question under every pricing question
Pricing is really a question about what kind of practice you're building and how fast. A fee designed to keep the schedule full is very different from one designed to keep you sustainable. I call that decision Stop, Slow, or Go. If you price to fill every slot, you've picked Go. If you price to protect your time and your family, you've picked something else, and that's a perfectly legitimate answer.
Frequently asked questions
How much should a concierge doctor charge? There's no universal number. It comes from your panel size, your costs, and your income goal. Some physicians land at a few thousand dollars a year, and others, with small panels and very deep access, charge $25,000 or more.
How do I know if I can charge $10,000 per patient? Two things need to be true: you can deliver a noticeably different level of access and coordination, and the patients you want to serve value it enough to pay for it. If you can't describe what they're getting in a couple of sentences, you're not ready to charge it yet.
Should I price per person or per family? Lots of practices offer family pricing with lower rates for additional members. Just make sure the extra people don't push you past the panel size you chose.
How often should I raise my fee? Review it every year against your costs and capacity, even if you decide not to change it.
Is a bigger panel at a lower price ever the right call? Sometimes. If you want more patients and have the team and systems to support them, that can work. Just make that choice on purpose instead of by default.
Want a second set of eyes on your pricing? I offer a free 30-minute Meet & Greet. It's a conversation, not a sales call. [Book a Meet & Greet]
This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Talk to a qualified professional about your state and situation
Source
Healthcare Dive, "Doctors slam Medicare cuts in 2026 fee schedule" (AMA figure on Medicare payment since 2001): healthcaredive.com

